in on blogging

my bestblogforward (how blogposts become popular)

BestBlogForward

I mentioned before Kevin Lim’s BestBlogForward meme. Here’s my contribution :)

Judging by visits and comments, there are probably three blog posts that stand out as ‘most popular’ from this blog. They are:

Based on my experience with these posts… here’s what I’ve learned about how blog posts get popular. (Note: that’s very different to ‘how to write popular blog posts’. I’m not the person to write that post, I don’t think.)

  1. If you’re a mid-to-low alphabet lister like myself… you need the network to make anything you write widely read (or viewed, at least). In each of these cases, I’m indebted to at least one blogger much more popular than myself to get eyeballs on these posts. Once one of these ‘popular’ bloggers links to you, then it becomes a bit of a snowball effect (or a meme, I guess… hence TechMeme). Interestingly, I’ve had posts on TechMeme a few times now and get virtually no traffic as a result. Bloggers who I really have to thank include Scrivs at 9 Rules, Kathy Sierra, Ben Barren, Anne Zelenka.
  2. If your blog title has a number in it, then it is more likely to be popular. No matter what people say about blogposts that are lists (and it’s often not good), there’s something about a number that sounds authoritative and that people can’t seem to resist reading and linking to. As I discovered, it doesn’t even matter if the number you choose is different to the actual number of species (my six species was actually seven, but hardly anyone mentioned that – thank goodness!). I don’t want to recommend overdoing the ‘number’ posts though… I haven’t done one before or since the six species… I should probably think up another one though :)
  3. Some conversations never die and seem to be eternally popular. In my case, my brushes with the “Ugly Design debate” and the “Where are the Women Bloggers” debate were a lot more high impact than I’d expected. At the time of writing, I wasn’t really aware that these discussions had been going on in the blogosphere for years already, and since I’ve written them I’ve seen them bubble up from time to time.
  4. There is no relationship between the length of your blog title and it’s popularity.

What were the stories behind these posts? Well, I can honestly say that none of them were written with ‘traffic’ in mind. Each of them came from conversations I was having online and offline (Six Species, Women of 2.0), things that were bugging me at the time (Design is a good idea), or someone writing a blog post that consolidated some of my thoughts in a new way and inspired me to post my interpretation of what they were saying (User Experience & Cognitive Pleasure).

Based on my experience with TechMeme, I’d say that if you want to be ‘popular’, it’s probably not that difficult. Write about what everyone else is writing about as soon as you possibly can, and – with bit of strategic promotion and A-Lister flattery – get drawn into the linking maelstrom.

Is this what you want your blog to be though? For me, absolutely no. Occasionally there’s something ‘topical’ that I think is exciting or interesting or annoying, and that is relevant to the work that I do (or my life I guess). A lot of the time, the topics that the blogosphere carries on with are repetitive, reactive, and irrelevant to what I’m interested in.

For me, I’d much rather have a small band of people who read my blog reasonably regularly, and who find what I write to be somewhat thought provoking – either to help them think about something in a new way, or to introduce them to something that they might not have seen before. I’m much more interested in people reading and interacting in a conversation than I am in having thousands of anonymous visitors drop in for a moment, then drop out. (On a slight tangent, that’s why I don’t have Adsense or any other advertising on my blog).

So, popular blogposts. I like it when I have a post that’s popular because I get to ‘meet’ new people who find my blog that way… but I don’t write for popularity or traffic.

I’d encourage *everyone* to write for reasons other than popularity. But that’s just me.

If you *really* want to learn about popularity (and making money from your blog), go see Darren Rowse. (and ponder on the fact that 73%* of his readers are male… more on that later perhaps)

* based on results of poll at time of writing. Results were even more skewed towards men last time I checked so perhaps women bloggers just have better things to do on the weekend!)

Image credit: Borrowed from Kevin

Technorati Tags:

  1. Leisa, you’re so on the money. I’ve been following your blog since you first dropped a comment on mine (major points there). I’ve seen your blog grow in readership simply because you’ve made plenty of conversations with others bloggers.

    The posts you’ve mentioned make sense in terms of popularity and the self-analysis you’ve provided would be useful to many (including yourself I’m sure). While popularity shouldn’t be the sole motivation for blogging, it doesn’t hurt to figure out how to title blog posts, because I do spend a lot of time figuring mine out!

    Like you, I am now interested in getting passionate readers, rather than a big band of faceless subscribers. In fact, this was reflected in my decision to make the blog a real mirror of my life (which is colorful and varied), rather than topical (e.g. specific to Mac & Web 2.0 only). I know this might turn some readers off, but I had to figure out who my users were… and I realized that the biggest user was simply me.

    Great job there and thanks for sharing your thoughts!

  2. Hey, I’ve joined too. I think it really is a great meme that allows for finding new blogs (like yours, hehe).

    I agree with the ‘small band of readers’. There is so much more pleasure to be had and it leads to interesting conversations and some wonderful friendships.

    The number thing: you’re right but actually I’ve come to find them a bit of a bore, especially when it’s about five ways to make more money’. That sort of thing.

    Good luck with the contest!

  3. hi Stowe – thanks for the heads up! (I think another tip for making popular posts is being more committed to copy-editing than I am!)

    Stowe is another ‘much more popular than I’ blogger that I should have mentioned above :)

    hey Napfisk – I thought he number thing was a bit of a bore too…. but the stats don’t lie. Perhaps people aren’t doing a lot of ‘number blogs’ about Information Architecture tho, I might have a reasonably fresh audience? (Although, IAs have been using the number thing for all kinds of rules for ages…)

    good luck to you too! (Although, i have to say I keep forgetting it’s a contest – it’s really just a interesting meme!)

  4. I like what you’re saying about purpose, Leisa. And that’s precisely what brings me here anytime – what’s Leisa been up to, what has caught Leisa’s eye, what does she think?
    That’s one of the best things blogging can provide to people who are naturally browse-style researchers (hem, that’s me). You find someone whose ideas and writing are usually a little more focussed or take a slightly different perspective, and go see ‘em every now and again.
    And if there’s a few popular posts as well that’s all the better, innit? Keep up the good stuff. (And have a great holiday, too – I’m a late visitor here.)

Comments are closed.